Meen Rashi Boy and Makar Rashi Girl: Kundli Matching by Rashi
A Meen (Pisces) Rashi boy and a Makar (Capricorn) Rashi girl earn 12–13 of the 15 Guna Milan points that depend on the Moon signs alone - Varna 1/1, Vashya 1–2/2, Graha Maitri 3/5 and Bhakoot 7/7. With their birth stars the total ranges from 15.5 to 29.5 of 36 across the 81 nakshatra-pada pairings these two signs allow; 73 of them (90%) reach the conventional 18, and 36 (44%) carry Nadi dosha.
Meen (Pisces) · Makar (Capricorn) · every number computed from the Drik Panchang koota tablesBy Sheela Goklani, Gold Medal, Master of Astrology
From the Moon signs alone
No Bhakoot dosha: the Moon signs sit 3/11 (Tri-Ekadash) from each other and earn the full 7 points. The birth stars decide the rest - the same two Rashis can score anywhere from 15.5 to 29.5.
Get the exact score with both birth detailsFree, all eight kootas, Nadi and Bhakoot flags, Mangal dosha for both.
- Moon-sign points
- 12–13 of 15
- Full range with birth stars
- 15.5–29.5 of 36
- Pairings reaching 18
- 73 of 81 (90%)
What the two Moon signs settle (15 points)
Four of the eight kootas depend on the Rashi, so they are the same for every Meen boy and Makar girl whatever their birth stars (Vashya splits Dhanu and Makara at 15°, hence the range).
| Koota | Boy | Girl | Points |
|---|---|---|---|
| VarnaMoon sign (one direction) | Brahmin | Vaishya | 1 / 1 |
| VashyaMoon sign (half-sign for Dhanu, Makara) | Jalachara (water) | Chatushpada (four-footed) / Jalachara (water) | 1–2 / 2 |
| Graha MaitriSign lords | Jupiter | Saturn | 3 / 5 |
| Bhakoot3/11 relationship | Meena | Makara | 7 / 7 |
| Moon-sign total | 12–13 / 15 | ||
Graha Maitri. Meen is ruled by Jupiter and Makar by Saturn. Jupiter regards Saturn as neutral and Saturn regards Jupiter as neutral: 3 of 5 for mental harmony and friendship.
Bhakoot. Meena and Makara form the Tri-Ekadash (3/11) relationship. That is not a dosha pairing, so Bhakoot earns the full 7 points for emotional bond and family welfare.
Varna. Meen is Brahmin and Makar is Vaishya; the point is given when the boy's varna is the same as or higher than the girl's, so here it is earned.
What the birth stars decide (21 points)
Meen Rashi holds Purva Bhadrapada (pada 4), Uttara Bhadrapada (pada 1, 2, 3, 4) and Revati (pada 1, 2, 3, 4); Makar Rashi holds Uttara Ashadha (pada 2, 3, 4), Shravana (pada 1, 2, 3, 4) and Dhanishta (pada 1, 2). Tara, Yoni, Gana and Nadi come from the pair of stars, so each cell below is a different match. Ranges cover the padas inside the cell.
| Boy ↓ · Girl → | Uttara Ashadha | Shravana | Dhanishta |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purva Bhadrapada | 29.5 / 36Gana 6 · Yoni 2 · Tara 1.5 | 28.5–29.5 / 36Gana 5 · Yoni 2 · Tara 1.5 | 26.5 / 36Gana 0 · Yoni 4 · Tara 1.5 |
| Uttara Bhadrapada | 29.5 / 36Gana 6 · Yoni 2 · Tara 1.5 | 28.5–29.5 / 36Gana 5 · Yoni 2 · Tara 1.5 | 15.5 / 36Nadi dosha · Gana 0 · Yoni 1 · Tara 1.5 |
| Revati | 21.5 / 36Nadi dosha · Gana 6 · Yoni 2 · Tara 1.5 | 21.5–22.5 / 36Nadi dosha · Gana 6 · Yoni 2 · Tara 1.5 | 22.5 / 36Gana 0 · Yoni 0 · Tara 1.5 |
Green: can reach 25 (very good). Red: cannot reach 18. Nadi dosha is 0 of 8 and flagged, never cancelled; the classical exceptions are listed by the calculator for an astrologer to weigh.
Best pairing: Purva Bhadrapada boy with Uttara Ashadha girl, up to 29.5 of 36 (very good). Weakest: Uttara Bhadrapada with Dhanishta, as low as 15.5. The same two Rashis therefore span 14 points depending on the stars - which is why a Rashi-only match is never the last word.
What the 36 points cannot tell you
- Mangal dosha for each chart and whether an exception applies
- The 7th house and its lord in both charts, and the Navamsa (D9)
- Whether both are running Dasha periods that support marriage now
- A vivah muhurat for the city where the wedding happens
Sheela Goklani reads both charts together, live on Google Meet, from anywhere in the world.
Frequently asked questions
- Is a Meen Rashi boy and Makar Rashi girl a good match for marriage?
- By Ashtakoot Guna Milan the Moon signs alone give 12–13 of 15 points, with Bhakoot clear. The full score depends on the birth stars: across the 81 possible nakshatra-pada pairings it runs from 15.5 to 29.5 of 36, averaging 24.6, and 73 pairings reach 18. The best star pairing is Purva Bhadrapada (boy) with Uttara Ashadha (girl), up to 29.5; the weakest is Uttara Bhadrapada with Dhanishta, as low as 15.5. Enter both birth details in the calculator for the exact figure.
- Do Meen and Makar Rashi have Bhakoot dosha?
- No. Meena and Makara are 3/11 from each other (Tri-Ekadash), which is not a Bhakoot dosha relationship, so the full 7 points are earned.
- Can Meen boy and Makar girl have Nadi dosha?
- Nadi depends on the birth stars, not the Rashi. Of the 81 star-pada pairings these two signs allow, 36 share a Nadi and so carry Nadi dosha (0 of 8). Meen Rashi holds Purva Bhadrapada, Uttara Bhadrapada, Revati; Makar Rashi holds Uttara Ashadha, Shravana, Dhanishta. The table on this page shows which star pairs clash.
- What is the Graha Maitri between Meen and Makar Rashi?
- Meen is ruled by Jupiter and Makar by Saturn. Jupiter treats Saturn as neutral and Saturn treats Jupiter as neutral, which scores 3 of 5. Graha Maitri is read for mental harmony and friendship.
- What about Makar boy and Meen girl?
- Varna is read in one direction (the boy's varna should equal or exceed the girl's), Gana scores differ in two cells, and Tara is counted both ways, so swapping the roles can change the score. See the Makar boy and Meen girl page for that pairing.
- Is matching by Rashi enough?
- No. The Rashi fixes only 15 of the 36 points; Tara, Yoni, Gana and Nadi (21 points) come from the two birth stars, which need the date, time and place of birth. Guna Milan itself reads only the Moon - Mangal dosha, the 7th house, the Navamsa and both partners' Dasha periods are read in a consultation.
- Are these numbers the same as other websites?
- They follow Drik Panchang's koota tables (checked on 134 of 136 worked examples; the other two differ only because Drik cancels Nadi dosha automatically, which we flag instead). Some software grades Yoni, Vashya and Gana cells differently, so a score elsewhere can differ by a point or two.
Roles swapped: Makar boy and Meen girl. All pairs: kundli matching by Rashi. Also for these signs: Meen Sade Sati dates, Makar Sade Sati dates, Meen Rashifal, Makar Rashifal, vivah muhurat dates, Meen Shani Dhaiya, Makar Shani Dhaiya. What a total means: 15 gunas, 18 gunas, 29 gunas or any score 0-36. Spouse planet for each partner: Darakaraka calculator.
